
INDIA bloc seeks SC nod to question CEC on SIR, submits 48 queries
Oppn parties are seeking explanations from CEC Gyanesh Kumar and other officials on decision-making, alleged dissent within the poll panel, voter database access, and ECINET audit trails
The Congress on Monday (November 16) alleged that the Election Commission has not answered its questions on alleged vote "theft" and said the INDIA bloc has sought the Supreme Court's permission to question the Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, and other senior officials, including Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu, and has submitted a list of 48 questions in this regard.
"...Who decided to conduct the SIR across the country? Who decided to change 'Form 6'? Who decided to centralize ERONET and ECINET and keep the voter list under central control?" the Congress said on X.
The opposition parties in the INDIA bloc have sought permission to formally question the Election Commission of India (ECI) over its conduct of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, alleging that the poll body has made assertions in court without furnishing relevant facts and supporting documents.
The Opposition argued that the information sought was exclusively available with the Election Commission and that the questions were necessary to verify the claims made by the constitutional body, rather than initiate a fishing enquiry.
Questions over nationwide SIR decision
A key focus of the application is the ECI's decision to undertake a nationwide SIR. The petitioners have sought details of when and how the decision was taken, the approval process followed, and whether all members of the Commission were in agreement.
They have also flagged an apparent contradiction between the Commission's 2025 order announcing the nationwide exercise and a subsequent response to a Right to Information (RTI) application stating that no information regarding such a decision was available.
Also Read: SIR row: Is Election Commission facing crisis of competence or intent?
The petitioners want the ECI to disclose the relevant file numbers, dates of decisions, and whether approvals were obtained at meetings, through file circulation, or electronic communication.
Alleged differences within the Commission
The application also seeks details of alleged disagreements among Election Commissioners over the SIR, ECINET, Form 6, and the filing of appeals.
The petitioners have asked whether Sandhu or Joshi recorded any written objection, dissent, or reservation between February 19, 2025, and October 26, 2026. They have also sought particulars of decisions taken by majority under Section 18(2) of the 2023 Act, including the identity of any dissenting member.
Database access and voter exclusions
Another major area of concern is the security and auditability of electoral roll databases. The Opposition has sought details of officials, private vendors, and contractors authorised to add, delete, modify, or restore voter entries, including those with privileged or write access.
It has also sought ECINET audit trails showing whether every change is recorded with the user's account, date, time, and corresponding order of the Electoral Registration Officer.
Also Read: SIR explained: From voter deletions to Form 6, what has changed?
Questions have additionally been raised over changes to the online Form 6 process, rejected or pending applications, voter exclusions, and appeals against inclusion orders passed by judicial officers in West Bengal.
SC hearing on Tuesday
The application forms part of the INDIA bloc's broader legal challenge to the SIR exercise. The Supreme Court has scheduled the petitions for Tuesday (November 17).
At the October 27 hearing, a three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant granted the petitioners 10 days to respond to the ECI's counter-affidavit. The Commission had maintained that all three major decisions relating to the SIR were taken unanimously.
Also Read: SIR voter deletions: Can INDIA Bloc turn discontent into a movement?
The Opposition has argued that the ECI, as the constitutional authority responsible for electoral rolls, should welcome the opportunity to place the complete facts before the court.
(With agency inputs)
