
2027 UP polls: Who’ll call the shots in BJP? 209-name list row exposes Yogi-Shah friction
Purported list of 209 candidates sparks rare public denials in UP BJP, exposing deeper tensions between Yogi Adityanath and the party’s central leadership
The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) appears to be grappling with mounting internal discord and factional tensions over the distribution of tickets ahead of the 2027 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections.
The latest flashpoint centres on reports that the state BJP unit, under Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath’s supervision, had finalised a list of 209 probable candidates and forwarded it to the party's central leadership for approval.
What initially appeared to be an early exercise in candidate selection has snowballed into a political controversy. Both Yogi Adityanath and newly appointed state BJP president Pankaj Chaudhary issued a joint statement on November 15 to categorically deny the reports that the state leadership had prepared and forwarded a list of 209 probable candidates to the party's central leadership.
Who will call the shots?
The joint statement described the reports as "completely false, baseless, imaginary and fabricated". It further asserted that the organisational process for selecting candidates had not even begun yet and that misleading information was being deliberately circulated to create confusion, distrust and apprehension among party workers.
The emphatic rebuttal, however, has done little to dispel speculation about the underlying power struggle within the UP BJP, particularly over who will control the party's electoral machinery and the question of who will call the shots in deciding candidates for the 2027 Assembly elections.
On the contrary, the controversy has once again brought to the fore the uneasy equations between Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath and the central leadership comprising Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah.
Yogi camp vs Shah camp?
Speaking to The Federal, political observers argued that the veracity of the purported list was almost beside the point. They said the unusual public rebuttal, particularly from CM Yogi Adityanath, was itself telling. Such speculations, experts note, routinely surface in the run-up to elections but this is the first time in the past decade that the BJP has felt the need to publicly denounce such speculations.
The episode, they argued, has reinforced speculation that all is not well within the state BJP, particularly in the relationship between CM Adityanath and Amit Shah.
“It is now out in the open. For the past few weeks, CM Yogi’s statements have been enough to suggest that the problem between his camp and Amit Shah’s camp has been on the rise. The recent denial of the reports, and the sheer manner, is sufficient to suggest that the centre is trying to cover up that rift. Otherwise it is not usual for CM Yogi to issue a public denial,” said veteran journalist Pramod Goswami.
Ghost of 2024 returns to haunt BJP
The controversy assumes significance against the backdrop of the lingering differences between the Yogi camp and the central leadership following the BJP's disappointing performance in the 2024 Lok Sabha elections in Uttar Pradesh. The party's tally had plummeted from 62 seats in 2019 to 33 in 2024. The party slipped to the second spot in the state and the Samajwadi Party emerged as the single-largest party with 37 seats.
After the setback, the party’s internal differences came to the fore. While the chief minister's camp was believed to have expressed reservations over the central leadership's unilateral decisions in the state and candidate selection, the Shah camp reportedly accused the state leadership of not being cooperative and supportive.
“After a series of meeting to deliberate upon party’s plummeting resonance among the voters in the state, it was reportedly decided to give CM Yogi Adityanath a free hand to deliver a victory for the third time in Uttar Pradesh assembly elections. This would not only redeem him but also open the doors to New Delhi,” pointed out veteran political analyst Ratan Manilal.
Yogi's unhappiness with SIR
The differences have since surfaced on multiple occasions. CM Yogi’s recent criticism of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls being the latest example.
Also read: SP-Congress seat talks: Akhilesh’s 'add 1 to 180' quip is the start of a negotiation, not a rupture
The chief minister raised concerns over the exercise and described the process as flawed as it resulted in the deletion of 1.27 crore Hindu voters. His remarks sharply contrasted Union Home Minister Amit Shah’s backing of the SIR.
"That was a clear indication that, despite what they are claiming in public, the rift between Yogi and Shah is widening as the election approaches," argued senior political analyst Anand Vardhan.
Before speculation over Yogi's remarks on the SIR exercise could be allayed, the controversy surrounding the purported list of 209 probable candidates had added fuel to the fire.
More than just a candidate list
Experts point to multiple possibilities that could be at play here. On the face of it, the release of the ‘fake list’ appears to be a pressure tactic from sitting MLAs and leaders from the Yogi camp to assert their candidature.
Given the BJP's propensity to drop sitting legislators and field fresh faces, particularly amid strong anti-incumbency, ticket aspirants are naturally apprehensive about being sidelined.
“That conjecture has assumed traction after the internal surveys of the saffron party has reportedly revealed a gloomy picture for the ruling BJP. So, naturally leaders are uneasy and insecure of being sidelined,” Manilal argued.
By asserting their candidature, that camp, experts contest, has given an underlying message that denial of tickets could result in a full-blown conflict within the state unit of the party and possible defections ahead of the elections.
Discord over organisational control
Another plausible factor, according to some political observers, is the growing speculation over discord over organisational control where there's a seeming rift between Yogi camp and Shah camp. During the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, multiple reports suggested that Yogi Adityanath's reservations over several candidates were overlooked by the central leadership.
There were also allegations that Shah disregarded the CM Yogi’s choice of candidates, including in constituencies around Gorakhpur. Since then, the extent of Yogi's authority in electoral decisions and the central leadership's control over the party organization have often been subjected to wider scrutiny.
Also read: Owaisi-Azad alliance puts Akhilesh Yadav in a tight spot ahead of 2027 UP polls
The appointment of Pankaj Chaudhary as the state president of the party and the placing of loyalists of the Modi-Shah camp in key organisational roles have further exposed the simmering tensions within the party. The selection of Vinod Tawde as the party's Uttar Pradesh in-charge has further reinforced speculation that the central leadership intends to retain a firm grip over the organisation and election management in the state.
“CM Yogi was as such not the first choice of the Modi-Shah duo in 2017. He’s the only chief minister who cannot be controlled. But he was backed by RSS and his vehement insistence to be the CM ultimately prevailed. Since then, there are many within the BJP who want to cut him down to size. A third term for him does not bode well for Amit Shah,” Vardhan argued.
Why the denial?
The Party has denied any factionalism and asserted that the talks are still underway to finalise the seat-sharing with the NDA partners.
“All is well between the state and central leadership of our party. We are contesting election under CM Yogi ji and there’s no two ways about it. The list that is going viral is fake and designed to disturb unity of our party. At BJP, we decide candidates after multiple rounds of discussions and deliberations involving top leaders and grassroots workers. We have begun the Chintan Shivir (brainstorming camp) in Mathura for the same,” BJP’s state spokesperson Dinesh Pratap Singh told The Federal.
While the public denouncement from the party has ostensibly been to prevent internal bickering within the party, the damage control exercise speaks volumes about the growing anxiety between the two camps.
Deliberate leak of list?
A senior journalist told The Federal that the list could have been leaked to bring disrepute to CM Yogi and establish that he doesn’t deserve the free hand in the elections that he has been vehemently demanding.
“There are many within the cabinet who do not want CM Yogi to secure a third term. It is highly probable that the list was leaked to put him in a bad light and give the central leadership an opening to take full control of the elections and candidate selections. For the Shah camp, the best-case scenario is that BJP stops short of an absolute majority and manages to come to power only through Amit Shah’s electioneering,” the senior journalist covering BJP in the state for over a decade said.
Also read: Punjab polls: BJP gives Raghav Chadha, other AAP defectors key committee roles
Lending weight to that argument, Goswami said the fact the sitting CM and state president issued a joint statement is enough to suggest that the entire exercise is a drill to allay rumours about discord between the Shah-Yogi camp.
“The party is now grappling with the same organisational disarray and competing factional interests that it has routinely accused its political rivals of. Otherwise, there was no need for CM Yogi and Pankaj Chaudhary to issue such strongly-worded denial,” Goswami concluded.
