A frustration with a criminal justice system in which trials can drag on for years and convictions are far from certain finds expression in public support for 'encounter killings'. Photo: iStock

West Bengal has seen five cases of 'encounter killings' since the coming of the BJP government in the state earlier this year. Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari has repeatedly defended the police, claiming they acted in self-defence. While there have been incidents of police violence under previous governments too, the most notable being that against Naxal activists in the '70s, experts insist any comparison would require study of careful historical context.


Click the Play button to hear this message in audio format

When Ratan Sheikh, a “history-sheeter” accused of shooting a police constable in Birbhum earlier this month, was arrested and taken by the police to a brick kiln in the district on November 15, he was supposed to lead investigators to the firearm he had allegedly used in the shooting case. Instead, police claimed, Sheikh retrieved the weapon and opened fire on the team. The officers retaliated, shooting him dead and making Sheikh the fifth person “to die in a police encounter” since the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) came to power in West Bengal in May.

Six days earlier, Dilip Roy, accused of raping and murdering a 13-year-old girl in Uttar Dinajpur, had been “shot dead by the police”. Earlier, in three other incidents, in West Bengal’s Baruipur, Gaighata and Samserganj, three men accused of rape and murder, or murder, were similarly “killed in police action”.

The five deaths have drawn accusations from the opposition that Bengal was turning into Uttar Pradesh (UP) under the BJP’s Yogi Adityanath — according to reports, since 2017, when Adityanath was first sworn in as UP chief minister, the state’s police have carried out 17,043 encounters, which killed 289 accused.

In West Bengal, Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari has in recent months repeatedly defended shootings by the police, saying the cops had his government’s backing to “deal with criminals” and retaliate when attacked. “If somebody fires at the police, will they shower flower petals on them or feed them batasha [sweets]?” Adhikari had asked reporters, while responding to questions regarding the Birbhum encounter case.

The state government's defence is also consistent with the BJP's political messaging before the elections. In the run-up to the assembly elections held in April this year, senior BJP leaders, including Adhikari, had publicly advocated following Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath's model of law maintenance, announcing that those accused of rape should be subjected to encounters immediately after arrest. Adhikari was particularly explicit in advocating extra-judicial action, suggesting that rape accused should be “jama niyei khoroch kore dewa uchit (finished off as soon as they are taken into custody)".

“The government's endorsement has found an echo among large sections of the public, including the families of some of the victims [of the encounters], giving the administration political cover to portray such killings as swift justice and weakening scrutiny of whether the police action was legally justified,” says Kirity Roy, a human rights activist and secretary of Banglar Manabadhikar Suraksha Mancha (MASUM).

Also read: Why drought in Maharashtra is more a manufactured crisis than simply a result of failed monsoon

Interestingly, even family members of those killed in the recent ‘encounters’ appeared to accept the police action as “deserved punishment”.

“He faced the consequences of his actions,” says Sandhya Mondal, mother of accused Prabhash Mondal, who was killed in the Baruipur ‘encounter’. “He never listened to me and was addicted to intoxicants.”

The Federal received a similar response from the family of Dilip Roy, who was killed in an ‘encounter’ in Raiganj. Roy was accused of raping and murdering a 12-year-old girl.

Speaking to The Federal, Roy’s mother, Chaniya, said she felt no remorse over his death, adding that he had brought shame upon the family. “It is better that such a sinful son is gone. He committed such a crime that we can no longer show our faces in the village. It is good that he is gone,” she said, speaking over the phone.

According to Dr Nazrul Islam, a former West Bengal police officer, such reactions point to a wider frustration with a criminal justice system in which trials can drag on for years and convictions are far from certain.

West Bengal, Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari has in recent months repeatedly defended shootings by the police, saying the cops had his government’s backing to “deal with criminals” and retaliate when attacked. File Photo

The National Judicial Data Grid figures placed before Parliament in December 2025 showed 3.69 crore criminal cases pending in India's district and subordinate courts. West Bengal accounted for 31.23 lakh.

“The backlog helps explain the public endorsement of a form of punishment that appears immediate, particularly in cases involving the rape and murder of minors. When people lose faith in the courts' ability to deliver timely justice, the killing of an accused person can be mistaken for the resolution of a case,” agreed political commentator and author, Amal Sarkar.

Questioning the legality of such police actions, however, Islam added: “The law does not sanction encounters. They are carried out by distorting the law.”

As lawyer Anirban Guha sums up, “There are established procedures for obtaining justice through the legal system, and they do take time. But losing patience because of these delays and turning to film-style justice [a reference perhaps to films like the Ajay Devgn starrer Singham series, which celebrate police brawn in the name of uprightness] is an ominous sign for society.”

Human rights organisations too have questioned the police accounts on grounds of both credibility and legality.

Talking to The Federal, Ranjit Sur, vice president of the Association for Protection of Democratic Rights (APDR), described the recent ‘encounters’ as extra-judicial killings, rejecting the police's claim of self-defence. Sur argued that a government could not escape responsibility for the actions of its police force simply by endorsing their version of events.

Questions are also being raised about the striking similarities in the official accounts of the incidents of recent months.

In Baruipur, Gaighata and Samserganj, officers claimed that the accused snatched their firearms during crime-scene reconstruction and opened fire. In Raiganj, the police said Roy fired at officers during an arrest operation. The Birbhum incident followed a slightly different version, with police claiming that Sheikh retrieved a concealed weapon they had gone to recover and fired at the police team.

Questioning the recurring elements in the police accounts, Sur asked, “Was the accused taken there at midnight [referring to the Baruipur encounter], with his hands free, simply to construct an encounter narrative? If a detainee tries to escape, the police are supposed to shoot him in the legs or below the waist. Why, then, was he shot dead? How could he snatch a police revolver so easily?”

Legal experts also reject the argument that such killings amount to law enforcement, highlighting that such actions undermine the rule of law.

“Killing a person in an encounter amounts to destruction of evidence. The accused might have been able to name five others involved in the conspiracy,” says senior Calcutta high court advocate Firdous Shamim. Former Rajya Sabha MP and senior advocate Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharya also questioned the purpose of the killing, arguing that the principal accused, if kept alive, could have provided information about the circumstances of the crime and those who might have been involved.

Also read: More expenses, less savings — what October retail inflation crossing RBI threshold means for consumers

Meanwhile, the recent killings have revived memories of Bengal's history of police violence. While the state has been no stranger to alleged police brutalities, experts caution that any comparison with earlier incidents requires careful historical context.

“The closest historical parallel is the anti-Naxalite crackdown of the early 1970s, when encounters became a recurring feature of policing in Calcutta. Suspects were allegedly picked up, taken to deserted locations and shot. The police often described those deaths as the result of attempts to escape or attacks on officers,” recalled Sukharanjan Dasgupta, a veteran journalist and author who has followed Bengal's history of political violence for decades.

Legal experts also reject the argument that such killings amount to law enforcement, highlighting that such actions undermine the rule of law. Photo: iStock

The Left Front's eviction of refugees from Marichjhapi in 1979, police firing during the Gorkhaland agitation and the killing of 14 people in Nandigram in 2007 were also among Bengal's most serious episodes of state violence.

“But those incidents arose from specific political and administrative confrontations involving refugee resettlement, a separatist agitation and opposition to land acquisition. They do not, by themselves, establish a recurring pattern of police encounters comparable to those alleged during the anti-Naxalite crackdown or in the recent killings,” Dasgupta pointed out.

While the circumstances of earlier instances of state violence varied, they do not remove the question of police accountability, which has remained contentious across successive governments in Bengal.

The Trinamool Congress came to power in 2011 promising an end to what it described as the Left Front's political repression. But during its 15 years in office, it too faced allegations of using the police against political opponents and failing to prevent custodial violence.

One of the most prominent cases was the death of 22-year-old Sudipto Gupta, a Students’ Federation of India (SFI) leader who died in April 2013 after being arrested during a protest in Kolkata. Gupta’s family and fellow activists alleged his death was caused by police assault. The cops maintained he had hit his head against a lamppost while being transported in a bus. The West Bengal Human Rights Commission later held the police partially responsible, saying his death could have been averted had officers acted more professionally.

A similar controversy arose in February 2022 over the death of student activist Anis Khan at his home in Amta, Howrah. His family alleged that policemen had entered the house and thrown him from the second floor. The state appointed a special investigation team (SIT) to probe the case, which concluded that he died after falling from a height, while holding five police personnel responsible for lapses during the raid.

The Calcutta high court accepted the SIT's findings as prima facie plausible. The family, however, disputed the findings and maintained that Anis had been murdered.

In another notable incident during the TMC's tenure, Sajjak Alam, an accused in a murder case, was gunned down by police near the Bangladesh border in Uttar Dinajpur in January 2025. The police claimed Alam had escaped custody and opened fire at officers, who retaliated. Then director general of police (DGP) Rajeev Kumar warned that anyone firing at the police would face a response four times over.

Ironically, however, the police in West Bengal during the TMC tenure had otherwise frequently faced allegations of “being soft on criminals”.

“The Alipore police station attack (November 2014), when cops were seen hiding under tables, and the Murshidabad violence (April 11, 2025), when the police were accused of failing to respond as mobs attacked homes and shops, are some of the incidents that reinforced the perception of a force unable to protect itself, let alone ordinary citizens,” says Debasish Chakrabarti, a political commentator and Commonwealth Fellow (UK). “This created public frustration and a demand for more assertive policing, which the BJP sought to capitalise on by invoking the Uttar Pradesh model during the election campaign.”

Also read: A question of ‘belonging’: What it means to be Muslim in Bollywood today

In its 2014 judgment in People's Union for Civil Liberties versus State of Maharashtra, the Supreme Court laid down safeguards for investigating such deaths. These include registration of FIR, an independent investigation, a magisterial inquiry and forensic examination. A police claim of self-defence does not, by itself, establish that a killing was justified.

The extent to which these safeguards have been followed in the five cases in West Bengal remains to be seen.

The state government ordered a judicial inquiry alongside a CID investigation into the Baruipur incident, while ordering CID probes, magisterial inquiries and forensic examinations in the other cases.

But announcing investigations does not, by itself, absolve the administration of its responsibility to ensure accountability, say experts.

“Unless the probes are demonstrably independent, examine the police accounts against forensic and other evidence and establish whether the use of lethal force was justified, they cannot be treated as proof that due process has been followed,” says Dasgupta.

For the BJP government elected on the promise of restoring the rule of law, the real proof of its commitment will be whether it ensures independent scrutiny of the five killings rather than allowing public anger over serious crimes to override due process.

Next Story