Marathwada has experienced drought in nearly half the years since 1901. The Union Agriculture Ministry had reportedly identified 315 districts as potentially drought-affected as early as June 2026. Photo: iStock

An open letter by economists, social scientists and activists estimates that an adequate drought-relief programme will cost Rs 1.66 lakh crore, against a government announcement of Rs 5,000 per farmer. But the crisis goes beyond inadequate compensation. Decades of irrigation inefficiencies, inequitable water distribution and regional economic disparities have left large parts of Maharashtra dangerously exposed to rainfall failure.


Chitaman Vitthal Bhoyar, a 49-year-old farmer from Dhanodi village in Yavatmal district, pulls out a stunted plant from his field, staring at it with helpless desperation. “Look at this, what will come of this,” he asks. His question appears to be directed less to the reporter and more to life itself, the uncertainty of which is simply too intense for him to be able to put it in words.

The pain in his voice finds echo in that of Parmeshwar Shinde, also a farmer and sarpanch of Ambesawali village in Beed district, in Maharashtra Marathawada region, who struggles to describe the heartbreaking sight of standing cotton and maize crops withering under the October sun. "The plants are supposed to be four to five feet tall and laden with cotton flowers. But because of no rain, the fields are completely dry."

His eyes are dry like the fields, his voice steady, but the lack of visible grief only highlights the extent of his loss.

Maharashtra’s latest drought is threatening to become much more than an agricultural crisis. With 304 talukas declared drought-hit following the failure of the crucial August-September 2026 monsoon, the state is facing the prospect of widespread livelihood destruction, mounting rural indebtedness, migration, food insecurity and a potentially devastating shortage of drinking water and fodder.

An open letter addressed to the Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis by a group of economists, social scientists and activists this month has put the scale of the required intervention at approximately Rs1.66 lakh crore. The government’s principal cash announcement so far, however, is an advance of Rs 5,000 per farmer, amounting to approximately Rs 7,500 crore for an estimated 1.5 crore farmers, say experts and bureaucrats The Federal spoke to.

The contrast is stark. But the more fundamental question raised by the crisis is why a state that has invested heavily in irrigation infrastructure and repeatedly experienced drought remains so vulnerable to rainfall fluctuations.

Also read: More expenses, less savings — what October retail inflation crossing RBI threshold means for consumers

Dr Neeraj Hatekar, leading economist and retired professor of econometrics and director of the Department of Economics at the University of Mumbai and one of the signatories to the letter, argues that the current crisis must be understood against the backdrop of structural weaknesses in Maharashtra’s irrigation system, water governance and regional economic development. “The failure of the monsoon may have triggered the crisis, but the extent of the resulting distress is also a consequence of how the state’s water resources and economic opportunities have been distributed and managed.”

The letter’s assessment draws attention to the severity of the rainfall deficit. In the 304 declared drought-hit talukas, rainfall was just 44 per cent of normal in August and 47 per cent in September, it said. In 210 talukas, accounting for nearly 75 per cent of the state’s cultivators, rainfall during these two crucial months was below half of normal. October brought little relief, with rainfall amounting to just seven per cent of normal until October 31.

The Maharashtra government’s own survey of 37,496 villages found crop losses “exceeding 33 per cent across 141.5 lakh hectares of the 166 lakh hectares under cultivation”.

The water situation is equally worrying. According to Maharashtra Water Resources Regulatory Authority records, as on November 2, reservoirs held 66 per cent of their capacity, against 89 per cent at the corresponding time last year. In Marathwada, storage was just 40 per cent, with reservoirs in Dharashiv, Jalna, Beed and Latur reportedly close to empty. Groundwater levels had declined in 223 talukas, while fodder stocks were expected to last only until February 2027.

Beyond crop loss, consequences may include nutritional lack, particularly for women and children, as well as students dropping out of education and the inability to purchase fodder, which could further threaten livestock, a crucial economic asset for rural households, say experts. Photo: iStock

For Hatekar, however, the problem cannot be reduced to rainfall statistics. He points to a “persistent gap between Maharashtra’s claims about irrigation potential and the actual extent of land receiving irrigation”.

As can be confirmed by the Maharashtra Economic Survey, Water Resources Department and CAG data, the state has reportedly created irrigation potential of only around 65 lakh hectares against a claimed potential of 120 lakh hectares. Yet actual surface irrigation appears to have stagnated at approximately 30-35 lakh hectares. More troublingly, experts say, there does not appear to be reliable data establishing how much agricultural land is actually being irrigated.

This raises uncomfortable questions about the returns on decades of public investment in dams, canals and irrigation projects. If irrigation potential does not translate into actual irrigation, the ability of farmers to withstand rainfall shocks remains severely limited.

There are also significant inefficiencies in the delivery and utilisation of water if one went by Maharashtra Water Resources Regulatory Authority data. Canal efficiency is reportedly below 60 per cent, while incomplete infrastructure and delays in project execution undermine the benefits of public expenditure. Water losses, including through evaporation, add to the problem.

The political economy of water allocation is another dimension that requires scrutiny. Hatekar raises questions about the “diversion of approximately 160 TMCft (thousand million cubic feet) of water through pumping arrangements from the Godavari basin towards the Tata and Konkan reservoir systems”. “The issue is not merely the volume of water moved, but also who controls its allocation, which regions benefit and whose agricultural needs remain unmet.”

These questions acquire particular significance when viewed against Maharashtra’s persistent regional economic inequalities.

The questions around irrigation governance have, however, not found much resonance with the state government's political leadership. When journalists questioned Maharashtra water resources minister Girish Mahajan in Jalgaon on November 7 about how irrigation mismanagement was contributing to and compounding the drought crisis, he dismissed the line of questioning as a political ploy.

“This is not the time to point fingers but to stand firmly behind our food provider, the farmer, during such difficult times and extend financial assistance through the CM’s Relief Fund,” Mahajan said, adding that he would personally approach people to contribute. He also appealed to financially secure farmers to voluntarily return the Rs 5,000 drought assistance announced by the state so that the money could help farmers in greater distress. The government had announced the advance assistance ahead of Diwali, and, according to Mahajan, had transferred more than Rs 4,372 crore to over 87 lakh farmers as of November 5. “Those who do not need the money should voluntarily return the ₹5,000, considering it as a contribution towards helping farmers who are in need. My appeal is to everyone who is financially capable,” he told reporters.

State agriculture minister Dattatray Bharne, meanwhile, sought to turn the comparison with neighbouring Karnataka into an assurance of more generous assistance. Responding to questions amid criticism that Maharashtra had been slower to declare drought than Karnataka, Bharne said the state was working on a larger relief package. “Without waiting for the Centre's help, the state government is working out a plan to provide aid to farmers in distress. Maharashtra's farmers will definitely get a bigger package than their counterparts in Karnataka,” Bharne said.

Neither minister, however, directly addressed the questions about water allocation and alleged irrigation mismanagement and structural weaknesses that are claimed to have repeatedly left large parts of Maharashtra vulnerable to rainfall failure.

Interestingly, according to the Central Water Commission & National Register of Big Dams, Indian National Committee of Large Dams and National Water Dam Portal data, Maharashtra has more dams than any other state in India — 3,700 of them. Yet somehow, barely 17–18% of its farmland actually gets irrigated. “How do you build that much concrete and leave four-fifths of your farms praying for rain?” asks Shantaram Andhare, an equitable water rights activist from Kopergaon in Maharashtra. He laughs and asks to follow the water. “Sugarcane takes up just 4 per cent of Maharashtra’s cultivated land, yet it guzzles nearly 70 per cent of the state’s irrigation water. While millions of farmers watch their crops wither, a politically coddled cash crop is drinking the state dry,” he alleges.

He calls the infrastructure built to fix this “a masterclass in dysfunction”. According to Andhare, “Decades of irrigation projects have been bogged down by delays, bloat, and a massive corruption scandal between 1999 and 2009 that allegedly swallowed thousands of crores with little to show for it. Then came Devendra Fadnavis’s flagship Jalyukt Shivar Abhiyan in 2014. The state poured over Rs 9,600 crore into digging channels and widening streams, yet failed to produce any measurable boost in groundwater or water availability. Worse, by ignoring basic hydrogeology, the project actually tore up riverbeds, accelerated erosion, exposed aquifers, and drained the water table even further, ensuring every successive rainfall deficit hits increasingly worse.”

For now, the immediate consequence of inadequate relief, Hatekar warns, will be a severe liquidity crisis among rural households. “The immediate impact, of course, is lack of liquidity to finance living expenses, agricultural operations as well as maintenance of livestock,” he says.

Also read: Why 2026 has been the year of the emergence of a new political vocabulary of dissent

For Landge (identified by first name only), a farmer in Yavatmal, Hartekar’s caution is a lived reality. Having invested approximately Rs 21,000 per acre in cotton cultivation, he has watched the harvest collapse to almost nothing. His family has been forced to pledge household utensils to stay afloat, he says.

Nitin Gangadhar Nagose, 34, a cotton farmer from Ichora in Yavatmal, expects just seven to eight quintals of cotton from his five acres, against his usual yield of around 25 quintals. With the season effectively lost, even a late spell of rain offers little hope; he says he may have to turn to construction work to support his family.

Given the extreme distress, Hendre (identified by first name only), another farmer, wonders whether agriculture was a viable option at all in the region. “A farmer can fight pests or a competitive market, but how will he fight the weather?" he asks, not really expecting an answer.

The impact could extend well beyond farmers who have lost their crops. Agricultural labourers will find fewer opportunities for work, while an oversupply of labour could push down wages for those who manage to find employment. Families may be forced to migrate in search of work, and those remaining behind could struggle to meet everyday expenses as food prices rise.

Hatekar warns of “nutritional consequences, particularly for women and children, as well as students dropping out of education, especially those living in cities to pursue higher studies,” and adds, “The inability to purchase fodder could further threaten livestock, which often represents a crucial economic asset for rural households.”

Sagar Pawar, a dairy and livestock farmer in Solapur district, cultivates eight acres and tends to dairy cattle, 40 sheep and a goat. But he has been unable to grow fodder on his land. His 400-metre-deep borewell, too, yields water for barely two minutes before running dry. "The Gram Panchayat gives us one tanker of water, amounting to 2,000 litres, once every four days. It is hardly enough." With fodder and protein feed increasingly expensive and difficult to procure, he is forced to ration what little he can buy. "I can only buy limited amounts of the required fodder and protein feed for my animals; hence, I feed them just enough for survival."

The distress is also cumulative. Several parts of the state have experienced significant livelihood destruction following recent floods and repeated hailstorms that devastated crops. The drought is therefore striking households that may already have exhausted their savings and borrowing capacity.

Marathwada is particularly vulnerable because of the scarcity of alternative livelihood opportunities and the region’s dependence on agriculture. “In many parts, this is coming on top of massive destruction of livelihood during recent floods, as well as repeated hailstorms that have devastated crops,” Hatekar points out.

He points out that the lack of alternative employment opportunities in Marathwada makes the consequences of agricultural failure particularly severe. “The drought has that extra edge,” he says, adding, “The impact on health, particularly mental health, is another important and often overlooked dimension of the crisis.”

The vulnerability is not confined to Maharashtra. Hatekar identifies Vidarbha and Marathwada, along with parts of northern Karnataka, particularly the Bidar-Vijayapura belt, as regions facing similar structural challenges. However, he believes, “The problems associated with irrigation management are particularly pronounced in Maharashtra.” He explains how the concentration of economic activity and urban employment around Mumbai and Pune has left large parts of the state’s interior dependent on agriculture. “Without sufficiently diversified local economies, even relatively short disruptions in rainfall can have disproportionately damaging consequences.”

The open letter also highlights a fundamental problem with the government’s approach to agricultural compensation: eligibility is linked to land records rather than actual cultivation. The Rs 5,000 advance, for instance, requires the beneficiary’s name to appear in the land records. This potentially excludes tenants, sharecroppers and women who cultivate agricultural land but do not hold formal ownership documents.

Hatekar considers this a “serious structural injustice!” He explains: “Sharecroppers, women farmers and others whose names are not on the satbara are already the relatively weaker sections. As it is, they do not get any benefits like farm loans, and other benefits like crop insurance or direct financial transfers.”

The result is a system in which those who bear the financial risks of cultivation may be excluded from compensation when their crops fail.

The signatories have therefore recommended that relief be linked to actual cultivation rather than land ownership, with gram sabhas identifying the cultivators entitled to compensation. The letter estimates that farmers have already invested approximately Rs 1.31 lakh crore in the failed kharif crop. It calls for “compensation covering the full cost of cultivation in the worst-affected regions and half the cost elsewhere, amounting to approximately Rs 1.13 lakh crore, or an average of Rs 80,000 per hectare.”

As an immediate measure, it recommends that the government release at least Rs 25,600 crore, equivalent to the compensation rates it offered following last year’s floods. The government’s offer of loan restructuring is another major point of contention, the letter flags.

Under the applicable RBI rules, accounts more than 30 days overdue as on September 25, 2026, are excluded from the restructuring arrangement. The signatories estimate that approximately 45 per cent of Maharashtra’s Kisan Credit Card accounts, including those already overdue or classified as non-performing assets, could consequently be excluded. Even for those eligible, restructuring does not eliminate the debt. It postpones repayment, potentially adding to the financial burden.

“Given the current situation where a substantial percentage of Kisan Credit Card accounts are already NPA, debt restructuring will be only a temporary solution. The debts will still have to be repaid at a later stage. However, that may not be feasible since recovery will be a long-drawn process,” argues Hatekar.

The signatories are demanding a write-off of the principal and interest on crop and term loans in the declared drought-hit talukas, including overdue and NPA accounts. They also want the government to guarantee fresh loans for subsequent agricultural seasons and stop coercive recovery by banks, microfinance institutions, private finance companies and moneylenders.

Their argument is that postponing repayment obligations does little to restore the financial viability of households that have lost their crops and income.

The proposed Rs 1.66 lakh crore package is significant because it looks beyond crop compensation to the wider economic consequences of drought.

The signatories estimate that generating 30.2 crore person-days of employment until June 2027 would cost approximately ₹17,600 crore. They want “public works to begin immediately in every gram panchayat, wages of at least ₹350 a day to be paid within a week, an additional 50 days to be added to the employment guarantee and the seasonal pause on employment creation to be suspended in drought-hit areas.”

Another ₹17,200 crore is estimated to be necessary to provide monthly cash support until June 2027 to approximately 10.2 lakh households of elderly people, persons with disabilities and women caring alone for young children.

The looming livestock crisis requires an estimated ₹17,900 crore for approximately 14,700 cattle camps catering to 73 lakh animals from February 2027. The state would also need around 9,000 water tankers at peak demand to serve an estimated 85 lakh people, at an expenditure of approximately ₹650 crore.

The signatories additionally demand “universal ration coverage in the declared talukas, nutritional support through anganwadis and school meals, and weekly public disclosure of expenditure and delivery of relief, audited by gram sabhas.”

Also read: Why numbers tell only part of India's healthcare story; cost, access and outcome matter too

Maharashtra’s disaster response fund for the year stands at ₹5,718 crore. The state has sought approximately ₹31,000 crore from the Centre for kharif crop losses, but the signatories point out that assistance for rabi losses would have to be sought separately. They also argue that the state has not adequately sought central assistance for employment, household cash relief, cattle camps and drinking water.

The larger question, therefore, is not simply whether the government can afford to provide relief on the scale demanded, but whether it is prepared to recognise drought as a recurring economic and social emergency rather than an episodic agricultural calamity.

The open letter’s concluding argument is that the scale of public expenditure is ultimately a political choice. “Without adequate intervention, households will emerge from the drought poorer, many will lose assets, and some may lose their lives.”

The rains may have failed, the letter acknowledges. “But the larger failure is one of preparedness, water governance and the creation of viable economic alternatives for millions of people who have little choice but to depend on agriculture.”

Meanwhile, pushed to the brink of desperation, Bhoyar is contemplating pulling his daughter out of the nursing course she is pursuing because he can no longer pay the fees. Having invested Rs 2.75 lakh in cultivating soybean, cotton and tur across 3.16 hectares, he expects returns of barely Rs 90,000. Perhaps Hendre’s question of whether agriculture makes sense for them plays on his mind too. But he says little, silently staring at the land that was to sustain them, but tests them repeatedly beyond endurance.

Next Story