Big test for Vijay after SC nod on Thiruparankundram lamp; will TVK take DMK route?
x
With much at stake, experts say Chief Minister Vijay must make a call that will cause minimal damage. Photo: @CMOTamilnadu/X

Big test for Vijay after SC nod on Thiruparankundram lamp; will TVK take DMK route?

With bypolls likely, any decision will have political and electoral ramifications for TVK govt which positions itself as secular while keeping channels open with BJP-led Centre


Click the Play button to hear this message in audio format

The TVK government, which has positioned itself as a secular force, is now in an ideological spot after the Supreme Court on Friday (November 20) gave a nod for the Karthigai Deepam to be lit at the disputed Deepathoon stone pillar atop Thiruparankundram Hill in Madurai as a one-time measure. With only a few days remaining for the November 24 festival, the TVK government is mulling over filing a review petition challenging the apex court’s order.

DMK defied HC order

“There is a consultation going on with legal experts on the next course of action,” said state Law Minister CTR Nirmal Kumar.

So far, the TVK has toed a line similar to the DMK on the issue. However, it remains to be seen how the government approaches in the future.

The DMK, when it was in power last year, refused to implement the order despite the Madurai bench of the Madras High Court granting Hindus permission to light the lamp at the contentious Deepathoon stone pillar atop Thiruparankundram hill, nearly 50 metres close to the Sikandar Badusha Dargah. While Hindu devotees call the pillar a traditional stone lamp-pillar and argue that it is historically appropriate to light the lamp, the Tamil Nadu government has said there are no records to establish the spot’s religious credentials. The Waqf board also claims that the surrounding area belongs to the dargah.

Also read: SC allows one-time Karthigai Deepam lighting atop Thiruparankundram hill https://thefederal.com/cat

Thus, the lamp last year was lit near the Uchi Pillaiyar Temple, which has been the traditional spot for many years. Citing law and orders, the DMK had at the time had taken a stern decision despite having to face contempt of court.

Will TVK go the DMK way?

If at all the TVK has been on the same page as the DMK, it's been on this issue. The TVK after it came to power, filed a special leave petition in the Supreme Court challenging the high court’s order. But with the Supreme Court now ruling in favor of the Deepam being lit in the disputed area, the TVK government has nowhere to go except file a review petition that can be taken up only on the eve of the festival on Monday (November 23).

While the DMK risked contempt with the high court order, observers wonder if the TVK could do the same with the apex court.

‘Issue being used for political reasons’

While arguments continue over whether the Hindu ritual should be conducted on land that the waqf board stakes claim to, stakeholders and archaeology experts say the issue has been blown out of proportion and made communal to serve a political agenda in a place of communal harmony.

“There is a stone inscription that confirms that the lamp was lit near the Uchi Pillaiyar temple for nearly 200 years in history. It has been recorded in books by the Tamil Nadu Archaeology Department. It was also submitted to the high court last year. But the court turned a blind eye and followed a preconceived notion. Never in history has a lamp been lit near the dargah. The issue has been blown out of proportion for political reasons,” former assistant director of state Archaeology Department C Santhalingam told The Federal.

Also read: The sacred hill of Madurai: Two faiths and one dispute

Thiruparankundram’s history spans over 2,000 years, with Jain rock beds and Tamil inscriptions providing evidence of its antiquity. Sangam literature celebrates it as Murugan’s sacred hill and the first of his six abodes, Santhalingam said. It was only in the early 1900s that Deepam-related tensions flared up only after Hindu outfits raked it up, he added.

“The government is the authority. The verdict by the Supreme Court itself is also very confusing because it also stayed the high court’s order. Our side’s argument was never taken into account despite providing much historical evidence. We met with Minister CTR Nirmal Kumar and also raised it with him. He assured us that he is going to Chennai today and a favorable answer will be provided tomorrow,” Thiruparakundram Jamat secretary Aarif said.

Between the devil and the deep sea

Political observers note that any decision the TVK government takes on the issue will have political ramifications, considering its willingness to have a ‘working relationship’ with the BJP at the Centre and its positioning as a secular party at the state level. All of TVK's allies, which keep the government afloat, have raised concerns over the Supreme Court verdict and have urged it to take a decision that is in line with public sentiment. The DMK has asked the TVK government to clarify its next course of action.

Also read: Thiruparankundram Deepam row: Experts debunk claims of ancient pillar

Political observer and senior journalist Tharasu Shyam said there has been a lot of confusion over the Supreme Court order, which has left the TVK government in a tizzy about how to move forward. “Ideally, the TVK government should file a modification or clarification, not a review petition because it will take a lot of time and the government does not have enough time for that. Review is never an urgency, but a modification can be,” he said.

Much at stake for TVK

Raveendran Duraisamy said there is a lot at stake for the TVK government, especially when the state is headed for bypolls.

“The government is in a fix on the issue, as its decision can have an impact on the bypolls. When Stalin opposed the lighting of the lamp at the pillar, it was in contempt of the high court’s order. But this time the TVK faces the Supreme Court’s order. If the TVK doesn’t implement the apex court’s order, it will be branded anti-Hindu, and if it does, it will be branded anti-Muslim. The government’s decision may have an effect in Trichy East, where there is a significant Muslim population. It will allow the DMK to consolidate the Muslim votes. The challenge for Chief Minister Vijay is to take a call that will have minimal damage,” Duraisamy adds.

Next Story