
New govt, old 'cut-money' culture: Bengal's investment push faces extortion hurdle
State's finance minister Swapan Dasgupta has publicly acknowledged that money demands from businesses, particularly real estate developers, remained a problem despite repeated warnings from the party's leadership
West Bengal’s attempt to reposition itself as an attractive investment destination is running into an old problem that the change of government has failed to resolve.
Six months after the BJP came to power promising to end the “cut-money culture and syndicate raj” associated with the previous Trinamool Congress (TMC) regime, allegations of extortion from developers and businesses continue to surface, prompting even the state's finance minister Swapan Dasgupta to publicly acknowledge the government's failure to eradicate the menace.
Speaking at the Bengal pavilion at the India International Trade Fair (IITF) in Delhi, he acknowledged that money demands from businesses, particularly real estate developers, remained a problem despite repeated warnings from the party's leadership.
Also read: West Bengal govt warns officials over service delays amid local body vacuum
He said restoring public confidence would take time, suggesting that the government needed at least another year to tackle the practice.
Behala real estate developer approaches police
The admission comes at an awkward time for the BJP government, which is trying to attract investment through a new industrial policy, easier land availability and assurances of faster administrative clearances.
“These measures may improve the formal incentives for investors, but they cannot compensate for an informal business environment in which politically connected intermediaries can demand money from companies to allow projects to proceed,” said a Howrah-based real estate developer who wished to remain anonymous.
The construction sector offers a telling example of how the change of government has failed to address the problem.
In the weeks after the BJP's victory in May, local syndicate operators who had controlled the supply of sand, cement and other construction materials appeared to retreat from several project sites, raising hope that the change in political dispensation would bring an end to the syndicate and cut money culture that had added to construction costs.
Also read: West Bengal CM gives police ‘free hand’ to retaliate in rape, drug, infiltration cases
But the hope was short-lived as complaints of extortion soon resurfaced, with developers alleging that local BJP functionaries and politically connected intermediaries were demanding money to allow construction projects to proceed.
In Behala, South Kolkata, a real estate developer mustered the courage to lodge a police complaint accusing local BJP leader Tuhin Pal of demanding money to allow construction work to continue.
Extortion complaints reach BJP
But not everyone has been willing to approach the police. The BJP's state leadership has been receiving verbal and written complaints of extortion from several districts, far exceeding the number of complaints formally lodged with the police, according to party sources.
This suggests that many affected people have chosen to bring their grievances to party leaders rather than pursue formal police action.
The Confederation of Real Estate Developers' Associations of India (CREDAI) recently estimated that the decline in syndicate operations and extortion could bring down housing prices in the state by Rs 100-200 per square foot.
According to association sources, developers continue to face demands ranging from Rs 500 to Rs 1000 per square foot, depending on the size and location of the project, with New Town and Rajarhat in Kolkata among the worst-affected areas.
The allegations however have not been confined to construction sector.
BJP workers arrested
Earlier this month, three BJP workers were arrested after the management of Eco Cafe and Lake Palace guest house in Deganga accused local party leaders of demanding security money.
Also read: Bengal's new industrial land policy faces test over tribal rights, environmental concerns
The management alleged that, after it refused to pay, the men assaulted the manager, vandalised the premises and looted cash.
The accused denied the extortion charge, claiming they had intervened over an alleged prostitution racket.
Earlier, operations at the solid-waste processing plant of Eastern Organic Fertilizers Pvt Ltd in Dum Dum were suspended for three days after a group of 40 to 50 men allegedly assaulted employees, demanded monthly payments and sought the appointment of people of their choice in different departments.
The shutdown had disrupted waste processing for six municipal areas.
Police arrested two people, while Dum Dum BJP MLA Arijit Bakshi denied any connection with the accused and said the dispute arose from protests by local residents over alleged illegal activities at the site.
Factory owners affected
Similar complaints were reported by factory owners elsewhere. In Howrah’s Amta, several factory owners approached BJP MLA Amit Samanta, alleging that people were visiting factories, commercial establishments and construction sites across his constituency, intimidating owners and demanding money in his name.
Samanta said factory owners had personally brought these complaints to him, alleging that the extortionists identified themselves as BJP workers.
In Barrackpore, local party functionaries, including mandal general secretary Sanjay Yadav, accused their MLA, Kaustav Bagchi, of demanding money from business establishments, including a renowned private eye-hospital chain.
Yadav said written complaints had been submitted to the police commissioner and the party’s state leadership.
Bagchi rejected the allegations as a conspiracy. He said the hospital had voluntarily donated Rs 40,000 to his foundation through a legal transaction.
Illegal collections from commercial vehicles, another practice the BJP had promised to stamp out as part of its pledge to dismantle the TMC-era syndicate system, have also continued to surface in several parts of the state, raising questions about the government's efforts to project West Bengal as a business-friendly destination.
Earlier this month, truck drivers at the Srirampur check gate on the Assam-West Bengal border protested against alleged routine demands for bribes, payments under the pretext of overloading and other illegal collections by checkpost personnel.
The confrontation with West Bengal Police turned violent, leaving several drivers injured and bringing traffic on National Highway 27 to a standstill for hours.
Allegations of ‘danda tax’
Hundreds of trucks were stranded before police and administrative officials from both states intervened. A probe was initiated into the allegations.
Prior to the November incident, truckers from Jharkhand too made similar allegations. In July, two motor vehicle inspectors posted at the Rampur checkpost on NH-19 in West Burdwan were suspended after a truck owner from Jharkhand accused them of demanding Rs 22,000 as “danda tax”, despite the vehicle having valid documents. The truck was carrying industrial material for a private steel plant in Durgapur.
In another incident, police arrested BJP functionary Rakesh Maji for allegedly stopping sand-laden trucks along with others in the Madantore area of Jamuria in West Burdwan district and demanding Rs 200 from each vehicle.
Police acted after a video purportedly showing the collection appeared on social media.
As the persistence of the problem raised questions about the government's industrial push, the Opposition seized on the contrasting statements by senior BJP leaders.
CPI(M) slams govt over contradictions
On November 5, Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari declared that extortion had been ended and said complaints from industry were being acted upon within 15 minutes.
Nine days later, finance minister Dasgupta admitted that the practice continued and said the government should be given another year to eliminate it.
CPI(M) leader Sujan Chakraborty said the two statements exposed contradictions within the ruling party.
“Dasgupta admits that extortion has not been stopped. It is becoming difficult to distinguish between the BJP’s face and its mask,” he said.
TMC spokesperson Kunal Ghosh alleged that BJP leaders and workers were increasingly involved in extortion and bribery, and accused the party of inducting former TMC members associated with such practices.
Until the government walks the talk, Bengal's investment pitch will continue to be undermined by the very business environment the BJP had promised to change.
