SC judgement on child pornography: Top court’s suggestions to combat it

While overturning a Madras high court judgement on Monday (September 23) and uphelding that watching and downloading child pornography are criminal offences under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012 and the Information Technology (IT) Act, the apex court gave a few suggestions on how to effectively fight child pornography.

Here are some of the suggestions made by the Supreme Court in its judgement:

Substituting the term child pornography

Notably, the SC urged Parliament to seriously consider bringing an amendment to the POCSO Act for substituting the term "child pornography" with "child sexual exploitative and abuse material". In this way it will more accurately reflect the reality of such offences.

"Parliament should seriously consider to bring about an amendment to the POCSO for the purpose of substituting the term 'child pornography' with 'child sexual exploitative and abuse material' (CSEAM) with a view to reflect more accurately on the reality of such offences," it said.

A bench comprising Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud and Justice J B Pardiwala said the Centre, in the meantime, may consider to bring about the suggested amendment to the POCSO Act by way of an Ordinance.

"We put the courts to notice that the term 'child pornography' shall not be used in any judicial order or judgment, and instead the term 'child sexual exploitative and abuse material' (CSEAM) should be endorsed," the bench said.

Implement sex education programmes

In its 200-page verdict, the bench also suggested that implementing comprehensive sex education programmes that include information about legal and ethical ramifications of child pornography can help deter potential offenders.

"These programmes should address common misconceptions and provide young people with a clear understanding of consent and the impact of exploitation," it said.

Role of schools

The top court suggested that schools can play a crucial role in early identification, intervention and implementing school-based programmes that educate students about healthy relationships, consent and appropriate behaviour and can help prevent problematic sexual behaviours (PSB).

Expert committee

"To give meaningful effect to the above suggestions and work out the necessary modalities, the Union of India may consider constituting an expert committee tasked with devising a comprehensive programme or mechanism for health and sex education, as well as raising awareness about the POCSO among children across the country from an early age, for ensuring a robust and well-informed approach to child protection, education, and sexual well-being," it said.

Therapy programmes essential

Suggesting that providing support services to the victims and rehabilitation programmes for the offenders was essential, the bench said these services should include psychological counselling, therapeutic interventions and educational support to address the underlying issues and promote healthy development.

The bench said for those already involved in viewing or distributing child pornography, CBT (cognitive-behavioral therapy) has proven effective in addressing the cognitive distortions that fuel such behaviour.

"Therapy programmes should focus on developing empathy, understanding the harm caused to victims, and altering problematic thought patterns," it said.

Public campaigns

The bench suggested that raising awareness about the realities of child sexual exploitative material and its consequences through public campaigns can help reduce its prevalence and these campaigns should aim to destigmatise reporting and encourage community vigilance.

Identifying at-risk individuals/problematic sexual behaviours

"Identifying at-risk individuals early and implementing intervention strategies for youth with problematic sexual behaviours (PSB) involves several steps and requires a coordinated effort among various stakeholders, including educators, healthcare providers, law enforcement, and child welfare services," it said.

The bench suggested that educators, health care professionals and law enforcement officers should be imparted training to identify signs of PSB and awareness programmes could help these professionals recognise early warning signs and understand how to respond appropriately.

SC squashes Madras high court order

These suggestions have come after the apex court set aside the Madras high court ruling that had said mere downloading and watching child pornography was not an offence under the POCSO Act and the IT Act.

The top court delivered its verdict on a plea challenging the Madras High Court order.

"For all the foregoing reasons, we have reached the conclusion that the high court committed an egregious error in passing the impugned judgment. We are left with no other option but to set aside the impugned judgment and order passed by the high court, and restore criminal proceedings…," the bench said.

On January 11, the high court had quashed the criminal proceedings against a 28-year-old man charged with downloading pornographic content involving children on his mobile phone.

The apex court directed its registry to send a copy each of its judgment to the principal secretaries of the ministries of law and justice and women and child development for undertaking appropriate course of action. 

(With inputs from agencies)