
Explained: Why Dawood Ibrahim's former Mumbai home is at the centre of a mosque row
Dawood Ibrahim's former Mumbai home faces a demolition dispute as residents challenge the BMC's notice, citing court orders and Waqf Board protection
The proposed demolition of Dawood Ibrahim's former Mumbai home by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) has given rise to a dispute over whether the remaining ground-floor premises are a mosque or a prayer hall.
What is the dispute about
The BMC has reportedly scheduled demolition work at Haji Ismail Habib Musafirkhana in Bhendi Bazaar for Wednesday (November 18) and Thursday (November 19). According to the residents, the premises are a 140-year-old mosque protected by the Waqf Board. However, the BMC terms the space a "prayer hall".
Also Read: India objects to UN report calling Dawood Ibrahim's D-Company 'India-based'
There is a legal aspect to the dispute as residents and Opposition leaders argue that court orders prevent the demolition. The BMC has held meetings over possible law-and-order problems regarding the issue.
According to an NDTV report, the BMC issued a fresh notice dated November 16 instructing the people using the ground-floor prayer space to relocate. It further stated that the building is hazardous and must be cleared for road-widening work.
Opposition cite court orders against demolition
Citing orders from the Supreme Court and the Waqf Tribunal, AIMIM leader Waris Pathan has objected to the notice.
"Issuing this notice despite stay orders from the Supreme Court and the Waqf Tribunal is illegal. This is a 140-year-old mosque. You cannot simply bring a bulldozer to a site just because you identify it as a mosque. We are merely requesting 15 days to present our legal case, and we will ensure that strict action is taken against these arbitrary officials," he said.
Also Read: Dawood Ibrahim's aide Salim Dola deported from Turkey, brought to Delhi in drug case
Congress MLA Amin Patel accused the BMC of conspiring with a trust to demolish the premises and seeking to bypass the requirement of a seven-day or 15-day notice, adding that the stay orders from the Supreme Court and Waqf Tribunal were valid for 2024-25.
Elaborating further, Patel said that residents did not oppose the trust's development plans. But their objection is regarding the pending case before the Waqf Tribunal, he said and argued that the parties should be heard before any demolition.
Building partly demolished after safety concerns
The dispute concerns the last parts of a building that has already undergone partial demolition.
The Musafirkhana once had 32 shops on the ground floor and 19 residential flats above them. It has been classified by the BMC as belonging to the 'C-1', a category for buildings considered extremely dilapidated and dangerous.
In the wake of a Bombay High Court order in August 2020 on a petition concerning its condition, the BMC began evacuating occupants and demolishing the upper sections. Around 10 rooms on the first floor and the disputed prayer space remain.
Dawood's family links and seizure of properties
The building is also linked to Dawood's family and criminal activities. Dawood and his siblings lived on the second floor before he left India in 1986. His personal room and an office were inside the premises. The conspiracy behind the 1993 Mumbai serial bomb blasts was reportedly hatched there.
Also Read: Lalit Modi: Quit cricket due to Dawood Ibrahim; ‘Rs 12 crore won’t last me a week’
Until the 1980s, Dawood and his gang allegedly used the property as an early base, storing illegal goods and smuggled contraband there. His mother, Amina Bi, continued living in the building after he fled abroad.
After the 1993 blasts, the government sought to seize Dawood's family properties under the Smugglers and Foreign Exchange Manipulators Act (SAFEMA). Amina Bi and Dawood's sister, Haseena Parkar, challenged the action in the Delhi High Court and then the Supreme Court. On April 20, 2018, the apex court dismissed their petition and ordered the seizure of the family's Mumbai properties.
