Graphic showing competing claims over industrial investments in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh.
x
There is stiff competition between states, including Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu, for greenfield projects and project expansions.

TN investment leak scare: A mountain out of a ‘mole’ hill?

An alleged TN investment ‘mole’ and data leak to Andhra Pradesh appears to have unravelled into a routine employee exit story amid fierce inter-state rivalry


Click the Play button to hear this message in audio format

After two days of hullabaloo around an alleged “mole” inside Tamil Nadu’s investment promotion agency, said to be “leaking” to Andhra Pradesh a pipeline of industrial investments meant for the state, it appears that nothing really happened.

It is now suspected that the routine movement of former employees between the two states, of their own volition, was turned into an espionage-style scandal that quickly fell apart.

Guidance Tamil Nadu put out a clarification last evening, stating: “As a responsible organisation, Guidance Tamil Nadu considers it its duty to address the ongoing rumours and clarify the facts in the public interest.”

It went on to “set the record straight regarding recent media reports and reaffirm our commitment to transparency and credibility”. There were no mass resignations, and TN “continues to have” “healthy and constructive competition” with neighbouring states, it went on to add.

There is stiff competition between states, not just Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu, for greenfield projects and project expansions.

Leak allegations

Media reports had claimed that Guidance TN 15 employees had been “sacked” for allegedly passing confidential investment information to Andhra Pradesh. The 15 employees had left Guidance TN in June and July. However, allegations of a “major data leak to AP” and the presence of “moles” surfaced only four months later.

Claiming that Tamil Nadu Industries department officials were upset over Andhra Pradesh securing investments that could have come to the state, the reports suggested that a group of former Guidance TN employees, allegedly close to former industries minister TRB Rajaa, had been pushed out under the TVK government.

While many of these former employees joined Guidance TN during the AIADMK govt, they were portrayed as part of a group appointed during the DMK regime and suspected of secretly working for the Andhra Pradesh government. Their exits were presented as part of a purge by the new TVK government.

The reports came days after some of the former employees announced their new assignments at the Andhra Pradesh Economic Development Board (APEDB) on LinkedIn.

“The government at no point said there was a mole or a data leak. It was the media and social media that made these claims,” a senior bureaucrat told The Federal.

Former employees allege intimidation

There appears to have been some professional discontent that triggered the exits.

In an email dated July 31, a copy of which is with The Federal, a former employee wrote to Chief Minister C Joseph Vijay and Chief Secretary M Sai Kumar, alleging intimidation and threats of being implicated in fabricated scam cases. The employee also alleged preferential treatment and pay disparities, claiming that two recently recruited staff members had received double promotions within six months.

The letter sought an independent inquiry into the alleged preferential promotions, a review of the concerned manager’s conduct and continuation in office, and a fact-finding inquiry into the alleged threats and intimidation.

However, Guidance TN’s note yesterday described employee attrition as a “normal organisational phenomenon”. “At Guidance TN, employees leave for various personal and professional reasons, including better career opportunities, higher education, relocation, and personal or family commitments,” the statement said.

The clarification did not address the allegations raised by former employees. Asked about the claims, a senior bureaucrat told The Federal, “It’s normal for any company to have differences. Even against me, there have been petitions in the past, but that does not mean they are true.”

Investment rivalry

The controversy unfolded days ahead of the TVK government's second investment conclave, scheduled for November 25, where it is expected to showcase investments secured during its first six months in office. It also comes amid opposition claims that Andhra Pradesh is outpacing Tamil Nadu in attracting investments.

Soon after the Guidance TN issued a clarification, former state Industries Minister TRB Raaja said the organisation did not address the key issues. “While much of the controversy centred on alleged ‘mass dismissals’, the statement begins by denying ‘mass resignations’. Two very very different things. Will those who carried the, now clearly wrong, message of mass dismissal run a story clarifying the matter. I don’t think so. Guess why? It’s because the entire story about some ‘mole’ seems to have been planted with mala-fide interests by some half-baked dimwits within the TVK machinery. They thought that it would be safe to blame the DMK for the present and future failures of the TVK regime as usual. The matter backfired spectacularly.”

Meanwhile, Andhra Pradesh Industries Minister Nara Lokesh took a swipe at the “controversy”. “Breaking: Andhra Pradesh’s top-secret investment strategy has been leaked. It's called ‘reply to investors on the same day.’ Feel free to copy it,” he tweeted.

Next Story