Modern Indian electric meter
x
For the Opposition, the issue is not merely the cost of electricity but the decisions that committed the state to expensive purchases and the accountability of those who approved them. Representative image: iStock

Keralam power purchases under scrutiny as Opposition alleges irregularities in VH Global, Himachal deals

The controversy involves a Rs 496 crore agreement with VH Global for wind power at Rs 11 per unit and the purchase of electricity from Himachal Pradesh through Power Trading Corporation (PTC) India at Rs 14.50 per unit


Keralam's electricity procurement decisions have come under increasing scrutiny, with the Opposition alleging financial irregularities in two expensive power purchase agreements and questioning the government's handling of the anticipated power shortage in October.

The controversy involves a Rs 496 crore agreement with VH Global for wind power at Rs 11 per unit and the purchase of electricity from Himachal Pradesh through Power Trading Corporation (PTC) India at Rs 14.50 per unit. The government and the Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB) maintain that the purchases were necessitated by an impending shortage, but questions raised by the State Electricity Regulatory Commission and differences between Chief Minister VD Satheesan and Electricity Minister Sunny Joseph have added to the political controversy.

‘Nothing but daylight robbery’

The Opposition has alleged that the agreement with VH Global violated procurement procedures and caused substantial financial loss to the state. Opposition leader Pinarayi Vijayan claims that wind power should have been available for less than Rs 4 per unit, against the Rs 11 agreed upon with the company.

Also read: Keralam admits to using Sahyog portal to flag social media content, 15,627 posts removed

"The agreement entered into with VH Global to purchase wind power at Rs 11 per unit, when it should have been available for less than Rs 4, bypassing all rules and without a tender or approval from the Regulatory Commission, is nothing but daylight robbery," Vijayan said.

He estimates that the inflated tariff alone would cause a loss of at least ₹252 crore on the Rs 496 crore transaction.

The agreement was signed on September 22, with power supply scheduled to begin in October. It was processed when MG Rajamanickam held the dual charge of KSEB chairman and Energy Secretary. The government has maintained that the purchase followed its directions. However, the Electricity Regulatory Commission has raised 15 questions, seeking explanations on the absence of competitive bidding, the failure to obtain prior approval and the circumstances that prompted KSEB to enter into a bilateral agreement.

KSEB’s explanation

According to sources, KSEB is expected to tell the commission that the purchase was an emergency measure to avert power cuts in October. Its explanation will cite the El Nino phenomenon and the possibility of a shortage during the month. The board will argue that wind power was not available at Rs 4 to Rs 6 per unit when the decision was taken and that the procurement had to be arranged at short notice.

KSEB is also expected to cite bilateral power purchase agreements entered into by other states, including Rajasthan, during periods of shortage to justify its decision.

Also read: CPI(M) demands judicial probe into UDF's 200-MW power procurement deal

The commission, however, has questioned why KSEB did not approach it before finalising the agreement. The order was signed on September 22, while the board submitted its petition for approval only after a delay of nearly one-and-a-half months. KSEB maintains that the commission was informed verbally and that the regulations permitted it to report an emergency purchase within 15 days of the government's decision. The commission has sought a formal, documentary explanation.

The actual supply under the agreement has raised further questions. Though the contract was for 200 MW, KSEB received power for only 17 days, with the average supply reportedly amounting to 36 MW. The board's explanation is that the agreement was based on the shortage anticipated at the time and that the subsequent availability of electricity could not have been predicted.

Opposition demands judicial inquiry

The purchase from Himachal Pradesh has also drawn criticism. KSEB procured electricity through PTC India at Rs 14.50 per unit. Opposition claims that the state purchased electricity worth Rs 282 crore from Himachal Pradesh in October alone, at a rate substantially higher than the prevailing prices on the power exchange.

Vijayan has questioned why the government opted for such an expensive arrangement without proper scrutiny by the Law and Finance departments. According to him, the Chief Minister personally approved the file without adequate examination. Vijayan has demanded that the government release all related documents and order a judicial inquiry into both transactions.

The controversy over the proposed GNA Energy deal has added another dimension to the dispute. The government had considered procuring 500 MW through the power trading platform at around Rs 8.48 per unit. The proposal was subsequently dropped, but the public statements made by the Chief Minister and the Electricity Minister Joseph exposed differences in their assessment of the procurement options.

CM Satheesan defends GNA deal

Satheesan defended the proposed GNA purchase, arguing that its quoted rate was considerably lower than the Rs 14.50 per unit offered through the Himachal Pradesh arrangement. He claimed that opting for the latter would have imposed an additional financial burden of Rs 2,232 crore on the state.

Joseph and KSEB, however, had favoured the Himachal arrangement, citing its availability during peak demand and concerns over the conditions attached to the GNA proposal. The GNA arrangement reportedly required KSEB to purchase electricity during both daytime and night-time hours, raising concerns about whether the board could use the entire contracted supply.

The GNA proposal was eventually abandoned. While the Chief Minister maintained that no formal agreement had been signed, the episode raised questions about the government's coordination on a major policy decision involving the state's power supply.

The government and KSEB now have to explain why electricity was procured at such high rates, whether the emergency justified bypassing normal procedures, and why the regulatory commission was approached only after the VH Global agreement had been signed. The commission's questions and KSEB's forthcoming response are likely to determine the next phase of the controversy. For the Opposition, the issue is not merely the cost of electricity but the decisions that committed the state to expensive purchases and the accountability of those who approved them.

Next Story