RG Kar protest: Standoff continues as Bengal govt rejects doctors’ talks preconditions

The West Bengal government has rejected junior doctors’ demands for Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee’s presence and a live broadcast as pre-conditions for talks to resolve the month-long “cease-work” and standoff over the rape and murder of a woman postgraduate trainee doctor at the state-run RG Kar Medical College and Hospital.

In a related development, the hospital authorities on Wednesday (September 11) deferred the hearing of the 51 doctors who were issued notice for allegedly promoting a culture of intimidation, endangering the democratic atmosphere of the institution. The next date of the hearing is likely to be Friday.

The meeting of principals and directors from all state medical colleges and hospitals called by Mamata on Thursday has also been postponed until next week due to “impending emergency works” at these institutes. District magistrates, police superintendents, Chief Medical Officers of Health (CMOHs) from all health districts, and other senior health officials were also scheduled to attend the meeting. The new date for the meeting will be announced in due course.

No politics behind protest: Doctors

Amid the 33rd day of protests and a sit-in outside Swasthya Bhawan for the second day on Wednesday, Minister of State for Health Chandrima Bhattacharya said the government remains open to discussions but suggested that “political forces” might be influencing the protests.

This led to a quick rebuttal from the medics, who dismissed the claims as baseless.

As an evidence of this claim, senior BJP leader Agnimitra Paul was greeted with “go back” slogans by agitating junior doctors near their sit-in outside Swasthya Bhavan, with Paul claiming she was merely passing through on her way to a nearby BJP office and not intending to politicise the protests, a claim disputed by a medic who accused her of making political remarks at the protest site.

At the protest entered the 44th day and the third day outside Swathya Bhavan, a large number of police personnel were deployed in and around the office of the health department at Salt Lake on Thursday, and traffic movement was regulated.

"We will continue our agitation and cease-work. But, we did not want to continue this. The state government is not open to holding any meeting with us. And, we want to make it clear that there is no politics behind our stir," one of the protesting doctors told news agency PTI.

Veiled threats from TMC leaders

Bhattacharya urged the doctors to rejoin work by respecting the Supreme Court’s direction to them, but refrained from giving a direct reply on whether the state government would take any punitive action for violating the apex court’s order.

However, TMC leaders and MLAs issued veiled threats to the agitating junior doctors by calling them “anti-nationals” and saying the party too might conduct counter-protests against the agitating medics.

TMC MLA Humayun Kabir, in a veiled threat, said they too would organise counter-protests as people are suffering due to doctor's agitation.

“A woman doctor has been raped and murdered. We want the criminals to be punished. But what is going on in the name of protests by doctors is unacceptable. If the people are dying as they are not getting treatment, then how come the doctors expect to stay safe and secure,” he told reporters.

Another TMC leader, Chandan Mukhopadhyay, criticised the agitating medics for defying the Supreme Court directive to rejoin work and branded them as “anti-nationals”.

Government’s invite for talks

The government had invited the doctors to a meeting at state secretariat Nabanna at 6 pm on Wednesday but the invitation did not confirm whether the CM would attend it.

Chief Secretary Manoj Pant, in an email sent at 3.49 am on Wednesday, urged the doctors to send a delegation of 12 to 15 members and stressed the importance of resuming work, citing a Supreme Court order directing them to return to duty by 5 pm on Tuesday.

“You will, no doubt, appreciate and agree that as a law-abiding citizen, it is everyone’s bounden duty to adhere to these directions. Unfortunately, it has not been adhered to so far,” Pant wrote, emphasising the need for doctors to return to their duties to provide necessary care to the public.

Doctors’ preconditions

Despite the invitation, the junior doctors insisted on several preconditions before agreeing to the meeting.

“We want the discussion to be held in the presence of the CM and be telecast live. We want at least 30 representatives as this movement is spread across various medical colleges and hospitals,” a member of the junior doctors’ forum said at a press conference.

The government, however, stood firm on its stance, refusing to accept any pre-conditions for the meeting.

Will request them again: Minister

Bhattacharya, alongside Pant and DGP Rajeev Kumar, urged doctors to resume duties, stressing the urgent need to restore healthcare services disrupted by the prolonged agitation.

“We were quite hopeful that the doctors would participate in the meeting. But they did not. No meeting can be held with so many conditions. We waited for them to turn up with an open mind, but they did not take any proactive step to resolve the situation,” she said.

She added that the doors for discussion remain open, despite the doctors’ conditions, but stressed that the government would not accept demands for a live broadcast or the CM’s mandatory presence at the talks.

“We will again request them to rejoin duties as per the Supreme Court’s directive and show respect to it. They must not forget their responsibility in this noble profession. They must not fall prey to the political provocation,” Bhattacharya said.

Demand for justice

The protests began after the body of a postgraduate trainee was found at RG Kar Hospital on August 9. A civic volunteer was arrested the following day, and the CBI is conducting a probe after a Calcutta High Court order.

The junior doctors have since been demanding justice for the woman doctor, along with enhanced security measures for women health professionals and the suspension of several officials, including the Kolkata Police Commissioner and the state health secretary, for alleged mishandling of the case.

In addition to security concerns, the doctors have called for the removal of Sandip Ghosh, former principal of the hospital, accusing him and others of tampering with evidence.

Doctors’ list of demands

The junior doctors have also emphasised the need for transparency in the ongoing probe and have demanded more democratic representation in official bodies to address the threats and issues faced by healthcare professionals.

The junior doctors indicated they would consider attending the meeting but would reserve the right to discuss the outcomes with their peers before announcing any decision.

Earlier in the day, the doctors reached out to Mamata, expressing willingness to meet “anytime and anywhere”, provided the discussion is streamed live.

However, a resolution is yet to be reached.

(With agency inputs)