
Calcutta High Court initiates criminal contempt proceedings against Abhishek Banerjee
Justice Krishna Rao's bench took exception to the TMC leader's public comments about judges, asking him to substantiate allegations of political bias in the judiciary
The Calcutta High Court on Tuesday (November 17) initiated criminal contempt proceedings against Trinamool Congress national general secretary and Lok Sabha MP Abhishek Banerjee over his disparaging references to judges and remarks questioning the impartiality of the judiciary.
A bench of Justice Krishna Rao issued a rule asking Banerjee to explain within 15 days why action should not be taken against him for allegedly attempting to influence judicial proceedings and making statements that could undermine public confidence in the judiciary.
High Court takes exception to remarks against judges
The court observed that Banerjee's remarks went beyond political criticism and amounted to criminal contempt of court.
It also took note of allegations that he had made disparaging comments about individual judges and sought to cast aspersions on the judicial process.
Also Read: TMC's Abhishek Banerjee questioned over ‘Gujarati gang’ remark against CEC
The proceedings stem from remarks Banerjee made recently in an interview and a video message in which he questioned the conduct and impartiality of sections of the judiciary.
Contempt plea raised during security cover hearing
The controversy came up during the hearing of a petition filed by the Diamond Harbour MP challenging the state government's decision to downgrade his security cover.
During the hearing last Thursday, the state's Additional Advocate General Bilwadal Bhattacharya brought an interview given by Banerjee to the court's attention.
Also Read: SC asks Calcutta HC to hear Abhishek Banerjee's media trial plea
He argued that the MP had made objectionable comments about judges, including references to individual members of the judiciary, and urged the court to initiate suo motu contempt proceedings.
During the proceedings the Bhattacharya reportedly stated that Banerjee had not only made “disparaging remarks” against judges, but also mentioned the names of judges. “The court cannot be fooled in this manner," he added.
Justice Rao challenges Banerjee to name judges
The intervention prompted a sharp response from Justice Rao, who challenged Banerjee to substantiate his allegations that certain judges were politically aligned with the BJP.
"Give me a list of which judges belong to the BJP and which belong to other parties," the judge told Banerjee's counsel, asking him to convey the challenge to his client.
‘Could have approached another bench’
Justice Rao also questioned why Banerjee had chosen to make public allegations against the judiciary instead of seeking relief through the available judicial remedies if he was dissatisfied with an order.
"If this court has not granted relief, he could have approached another bench. Several benches were functioning even during the vacation," the judge observed.
Also Read: HC lifts stay on arrest warrant against TMC MP Abhishek Banerjee in defamation case
Taking exception to the MP's public statements, the judge said an elected representative could not make such allegations against the judiciary without substantiating them.
He also remarked that Banerjee was an educated person and a sitting MP, and should be conscious of the implications of his statements.
In one of his sharper observations, Justice Rao said Banerjee appeared to be writing the annual confidential reports of judges through his public comments, suggesting that he was passing judgments on their conduct and political affiliations.
Banerjee given 15 days to explain remarks
The court's latest order follows these exchanges. It has asked Banerjee to explain why his statements should not attract punitive action for criminal contempt, particularly when he is himself a litigant before the same court.
The controversy also involves a video message released by Banerjee outside his residence at Kalighat, in which he spoke about alleged police surveillance and reconnaissance near his house. The state has contended that the video contained objectionable remarks against the judiciary as well.
Also Read: Calcutta HC halts demolition of Abhishek Banerjee's office in major relief for TMC leader
The high court has fixed December 8 for the next hearing.
Banerjee will have to submit his explanation within the stipulated 15 days, following which the court will consider the response and decide on the further course of action.
