US judge strikes down Trump administration rule imposing 4-year limit on foreign students' stay
The ruling follows a lawsuit by education advocacy groups, which argued that the restriction could discourage international students from choosing US universities
A US federal judge has struck down a Trump administration rule limiting how long foreign students could remain in the US. The ruling upheld the system that lets international students remain in the US while maintaining lawful status and making progress in their programmes.
Judge Dennis Saylor of the US District Court in Massachusetts ruled on Monday (November 16) that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) had failed to justify the change. He called the rule “arbitrary and capricious,” reported Politico.
What the rule proposed
Issued in July, the final rule set a four-year limit for F and J visa holders, regardless of programme length. Students who needed more time would have had to apply to DHS for an extension.
Also Read: Taj Mahal featured in US DHS self-deportation campaign offering USD 2,600 incentive
F visas cover academic courses and language training. J visas apply to participants in exchange programmes. The report said the number of visa holders who would have faced the four-year cap is unknown.
Under the “duration of status” system, most F and J visa holders could remain in the country while following visa conditions and making normal progress in their programmes.
What DHS said
A coalition of education advocacy groups sued over the rule in August, arguing that the restrictions would deter foreign students from choosing US institutions.
Also Read: Around 1,100 Indians repatriated from US in one year: DHS official
The policy formed part of US President Donald Trump's bid to restrict foreign student entry. According to the report, officials said it would deter visa fraud and protect Americans competing with international students for jobs.
DHS accused foreign students of having “taken advantage of U.S. generosity” by becoming “forever students”.
Why the judge struck it down
Saylor said DHS had failed to weigh the costs and benefits of the change. The department had not explained how the four-year limit addressed its claims about fraud or national security.
“Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity—providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States—that Congress sought to permit and encourage,” he wrote. “The statute simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority to undermine the F-1 visa program,” he added.
Also Read: DHS says green card applicants will not automatically be required to leave US
DHS had defended the restriction in a social media post by its general counsel, James Percival. “Come on a student visa, take one class per semester, and stay here for decades,” wrote Percival.
New international student enrolments at US colleges and universities fell 15 per cent this autumn from the previous academic year, according to the Institute of International Education, stated the report.
