Like honeybee draws nectar: Bobde on how govt should collect tax

The Chief Justice says imposition of arbitrary or excessive tax results in social injustice by government

Bobde was speaking at the 79th foundation day celebrations of Income Tax Appellate Tribunal | PTI File

Days ahead of the Union budget, Chief Justice of India SA Bobde on Friday (January 24) said the government should collect tax from the people without harming them, “like honeybee draws nectar from flowers”. Imposition of excessive tax results in social injustice by the government, he added.

Speaking at the 79th foundation day celebrations of Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, the chief justice said tax judiciary plays a very important role in resource mobilisation of the country and expressed concern over pendency of cases.

“A just and speedy dispute resolution is perceived as a tax incentive by the taxpayer. To the tax collector, an efficient tax judiciary assures that demands arising out of legitimate assessment are not strangled in delayed litigation,” Bobde said.

Also read | ITR-1 form not for those paying ₹1L in power bill, owning house jointly

The pendency of appeal cases related to indirect taxes in the Supreme Court, High Court and CESTAT has reduced 61 per cent to 1.05 lakh in almost two years.

According to official data, total pendency of appeals at the Supreme Court, High Court and CESTAT (Customs Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal) as on June 30, 2017, was 2,73,591, whereas the same significantly came down to 1,05,756 as on March 31, 2019, a reduction of 61 per cent.

With regard to direct taxes, as many as 3.41 lakh cases were pending before commissioner (appeals), while 92,205 cases were pending before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) as on March 31, 2019.

Asked about setting up more tribunals for reducing pendency in High Court and lower judiciary, the chief justice said, “You have to be careful that we don’t only transfer pendency.” He said people should know what is due from them and government should know what is due to them that can be achieved through early disposal of cases.

Also read | Judges presser last year nothing more than self-correcting measure: CJI

The chief justice said that while tax evasion is a social injustice to the fellow citizens, arbitrary or excessive tax also results in social injustice by a government. Referring to ancient laws in India around taxation, he said that tax should be collected from people like honey bee draws nectar from flowers without harming it.

Bobde also emphasised on the use of next generation technology artificial intelligence to expedite the process with caution that it should not replace the human discretion required for delivering justice.

“I am firmly of the view based on experience of systems that have used artificial intelligence that it is only the repetitive area or decision making that is rates of taxation or something which is invariably the same which is in a sense mechanical that must be covered by artificial intelligence. I do not believe that artificial intelligence should ever be allowed to substitute the human discretion which is necessary for a just decision making,” he said.

(With inputs from agencies)